Glacial Erratics

More reasons to keep on writing

August 05, 2003

A couple of things I read today deserve some more thought, perhaps mostly to get past my initial reaction: well, yeah, isn't that actually kind of obvious?    (0001FY)

That kind of reaction with these kinds of things is probably a bad sign.    (0001FZ)

Logic and Meaning    (0001G0)

First off, Erik Benson's been reading some Hofstadter, making him think about the difference between logic and meaning:    (0001G1)

The point I'm trying to make is that there are at least two levels here, and they don't communicate directly to one another--they don't speak each others' language. One speaks in rules, the other speaks in meaning. Meaning emerges from lots of rules, but does not work according to rules of its own. Meaning exists in latter level, but cannot be divided up into micromeanings on the bit level.    (0001G2)

This made me perk up; it resonates with some thoughts I've had about the differences between what can be accomplished with the psuedo-intelligence of computers and what comes from the complexity of human thought. I've always traced those differences back to my feeling that there is a fundamental difference in the way that computers and people do grouping:    (0001G3)

Erik suggests ways to create meaning in computational environments by allowing pieces to interact in complex ways that will allow emergence. That makes some good sense.    (0001G6)

No Now Now    (0001G7)

Browsing Teledyn led me to a press release about a scholar presenting a new understanding of time. Basic summary is that other models work with time as something that can have an instant. Lynds, the author of the paper, shoots this down arguing that no matter the interval of time described, that which is moving in time is still moving.    (0001G8)

If you read the article you'll see why this might be relevant.    (0001G9)

I liked it because it reminded me of my endless grumpiness with calculus and the notion of a limit.    (0001GA)

Comments

1/2
On August 5, 2003 05:24 PM Danny said:
2/2
On August 5, 2003 05:34 PM Chris said:

I know I know.    (0001GC)

I'm not sure why I can't get around to reading this thing. I think Sowa scared me off on the PORT list. Reading his mail messages is like being hit with a cricket bat.    (0001GD)

Sending...